Choosing the right payroll solution is crucial for small business success. With options ranging from complete DIY approaches to full-service providers, understanding each path's benefits and drawbacks helps you make the best decision for your business needs and budget.
Pros:
Lowest upfront costs
Complete control over timing and processes
Direct knowledge of all payroll details
Cons:
Time-intensive manual calculations
High risk of compliance errors
No automated tax filings
Requires staying current with changing tax laws
DIY works best for very small businesses with 1-3 employees and straightforward pay structures.
Online payroll platforms offer professional pay stub generation without ongoing service fees. These tools provide:
Automated tax calculations
Professional formatting
Compliance with state requirements
Cost-effective per-use pricing
This option suits small businesses wanting professional results without monthly commitments or businesses with seasonal employees.
Pros:
Complete automation
Tax filing and compliance management
Direct deposit capabilities
Comprehensive reporting
Cons:
Higher monthly costs ($20-100+ per month)
Less flexibility and control
Potential over-features for very small businesses
Choose DIY if you have:
Under 5 employees
Simple hourly wages
Time for manual calculations
Strong attention to detail
Choose Online Generators if you have:
5-15 employees
Need professional documentation
Want accuracy without ongoing costs
Irregular payroll schedules
Choose Full-Service if you have:
15+ employees
Complex pay structures
Limited time for payroll tasks
Need comprehensive HR features
Consider beyond just subscription fees. DIY mistakes can cost thousands in penalties. Full-service providers often charge extra for corrections, state registrations, and year-end forms.
Online generators offer transparency—pay only when you need professional pay stubs, avoiding ongoing fees while maintaining compliance and professional appearance.
The right choice depends on your business size, complexity, and growth plans. Start simple and upgrade as your needs evolve.
Retry
SM
Generate professional paystubs instantly with accurate tax calculations
Create Paystub Now